澳洲Peronal tax return story

在澳大利亚税务




Just interviewed this one client, indian guy, late 20s. first of all, i have to say that i have nothing against indian people.
the appointment was scheduled at 5pm today, he came in 20 mins late, which is fine, i was happy to wait. as he is the last client of the day before i go home.
the indian guy sat down, made it clear to me that he wants as much refund back as possible. individual returns are always tricky to do compare to business returns. with business clients, the larger they are, they more i can differentiate myself from the rest. with individual returns, anyone out of school, who has read the tax pack back to front. probably can do it as well as me. the key here is patience and asking as many question as i possibily can to maximize deductions.
after 40 mins worth of questions and answers, we came down to a final refund, $2600, not bad for someone with no rental properties. the indian boy's face froze when he heard the refund. as if he has just been told the most ridiculous thing ever. He was quite straight forward, "this is not enough" he told me. every year, i come across one or two clients who tells me that after 40+ mins of interviewing, my work is simply not good enough. This is fine with me, its not enough to keep me awake at night.  Good thing majority of the clients are still satisfied with my work.
I quickly scanned through all the deductions, told him this is the maximum he can get back without receipts/spending for the year. "but my accountant did everything i told him last year, and he got me $3000+ in refund". the indian guy yelled. i smiled, and slowly explained to him that he is responsible for his own return, and accountant who does everything he asks without explaining the consequences is simply irresponsibly. feeling very tired at the same time, it is already 6pm, its been a long day of interviewing clients. good thing the chinese lady who just left was very nice and understanding.
"i will go speak to my friend, please donot lodge the return." the indian guy said after a few mins of awkard silence. i sighed, feeling abit disappointment that i didn't get through to him and my work wasn't appreciated.
I passed all the documents back to him and handed him a invoice for $40 for my time (it is an hour now including waiting time). "i want to save my $40, why are you charging me!" the indian guy yelled again. he seemed shocked by the invoice, couldn't understand why i have billed him after spending one hour with him. "your chinese brothers referred you to me, saying you are very good, you get more money back for me" he added.
"they referred you, because they appreciated what i've done" i replied. grabbing the invoice by and tossing it in the bin. "please go, hope your friend can help you better than i can" i said, while waving him to leave my office. "i am sorry, you are not happy, are you?" the indian asked. he looked abit worried now as if i would report him to the tax office. "you can go now" i said, didn't want to waste more time. as i still have a telephone interview at 7:00.
anyway, for those who read this, i hope you would appreciate your accountant by the time he spends explaining things to you. not by the amount of money he can get back for you. because any accountant can the amount you want back for you, but to us, they are just numbers.....we are not ultimately responsible for producing the evidence. so next time you come across a monkey who does everything you tell them, think twice, you are better off doing it yourself because he/she simply does not care enough to ask you any questions.

评论
现在一般会计报税也就收几十元,包括了interview 的费用吧。
不过如果对新客户有15-20分钟的free of charge稍微解释下客人应该很happy的。
我总认为,找会计,就要相信他;不相信总是doubt他的工作,还不如自己来好了。

评论
Don't deal with Indian anymore.

In this world, only Indians you can't do business with them.

评论
please do not be racial here

评论
他们就这样,印度人都不喜欢印度人的

评论
It's not racial at all.

You can make friends with them, but do not do business with them. You will be crazy cause every indian wants bargain with you, just like some aussi don't want do business with chinese, but I think indians like bargain more then chineses do.

评论


Can't agree more

评论
这样事太多了。我都习惯了

评论
David, 不用太生气,我很满意你为我做的tax return, 态度很好,解释得很清楚,谢谢你

评论
我认识很多印度人,  他们比中国人还中国人。 1澳元等于6块人民币,但等于40块左右印度币.  所以他们对一块钱都很认真的。 中国人已经活的很stress了。 但印度人更stress.

评论
Can I ask how much dedcution LZ claimed for the Indian client?

评论
Indians can never catch up Chinese

评论
They are too selfish,mean, and can not help to hide.
More than that, they suck but like ridicule other people.
They are good at tricking as well.
Agree what Hornsay said do not do business with them, and I would say never make friends with them. Support LZ.
澳洲中文论坛热点
悉尼部份城铁将封闭一年,华人区受影响!只能乘巴士(组图)
据《逐日电讯报》报导,从明年年中开始,因为从Bankstown和Sydenham的城铁将因Metro South West革新名目而
联邦政客们具有多少房产?
据本月早些时分报导,绿党副首领、参议员Mehreen Faruqi已获准在Port Macquarie联系其房产并建造三栋投资联

税务

税务

父母国内的退休金在澳洲还要被收税么?

澳大利亚理论上退休金也算收入 但是研究了下中澳之间好像也有treaty http://www.austlii.edu.au/au/other/dfat/treaties/1990/45.html Article 18 Pensions Subject to the provisions of paragraph (2) of Article 19, pensions paid to a re ...

税务

朋友转钱给我大额,有风险吗

澳大利亚一朋友打算卖一套小房子,到手有大概小几十个想换成RMB,那正好我也需要澳币,想着说那我们就互换下,想着这中间有什么风险? 可能朋友卖的这套房还是亏损的,也不太需要交cap ...

税务

请问报税时medicare levy 怎么算?

澳大利亚rt,家庭退税2大2小的。 多谢回复,我们家2大一小有私报。小小娃没有。这样的情况请问medicare levy 怎么计算? 多谢! 评论 很简单,taxable income不低于$23,226的话,taxable income的的2%。 评论 ...

税务

在本地没有收入的父母需要申请税号吗?

澳大利亚父母有PR没收入,这种情况下必须申请税号吗?谢谢。 评论 应该不用吧 评论 同问,如果有存款,就有利息,是不是也要缴税,那么就要税号。不知我的理解对吗? 评论 对! 评论 沒有 ...

税务

1993年买的房子,现在如何证明自住豁免CGT?

澳大利亚我有一套1993年购买的自住房,最初自住了半年,之后将其转为投资房出租了5年,随后又恢复自住(适用于6年法则)。然而,由于时间久远,当年的材料并不齐全,目前只剩下零散的几 ...

税务

国内房产血亏两百万,可否申报capital loss

澳大利亚这几个月把国内房产清仓了,总共赔了两百万人民币,明年报税时是不是可以申报capital loss 国内买房时已经是澳洲citizen。 10月15日更新 刚才花了400刀咨询了会计师(包括其他一些税务 ...

税务

请教个人海外收入报税问题

澳大利亚个人收入一直比较单一所以没有用过会计,因为年初刚好从原来工作离职回国休假,国内朋友有一份不错的工作机会就做了半年,因为刚好是澳洲和国内各工作了半年,我在网上自己报 ...

税务

Mygov账户里养老金信息

澳大利亚4月份的时候换了养老金到HostPlus,但直到现在mygov里养老金信息都显示余额是0,知道我转到了HostPlus,但显示not reported 问了HostPlus,说他们定期都会update ATO,这个是ATO的问题,还说一般 ...

税务

Concessional contribution

澳大利亚自己交了2万【税后】到super。 【可能称为personal super contributions更恰当】 现在super里显示就是2万。 报税时,ATO已经在Deduction/Personal Super Contribution里填好了。也是2万。 这个正常吗? 评 ...

税务

请教几个报税的小白问题

澳大利亚请教几个报税的小白问题 出售ETF获得的capital gain是填在Managed fund and trust distributions下面的Capital gains那里,还是填在Capital gains or losses那里。看ato网站解释说前者是指fund distribution has ca ...

税务

換自住房的時候是不是賣了比較好?

澳大利亚最近剛買了一間房子當自住. 在考慮目前的自住房是要賣了還是轉投資房好. 假設在貸款還完的情況下 (沒有利息當 negative gearing). 我的理解是假設自住房2014年 100 萬買, 2024 年漲到 150 萬 ...

税务

收到银行邮件要求confirm tax residency

澳大利亚大家好, 收到NAB银行邮件要求confirm tax residency, 问我这个问题:Are you a redsident of any other country for tax purpose? 请问: 我是否需要声明说我在中国是a redsident for tax purpose?, 如果声明了的话会不会 ...

税务

错误pre filled信息,被税局气到

澳大利亚etax里发现一条pre filled信息,在business里有一笔60多万payment来自suncrop 我没有business,也没收到钱。联系税局让我找Suncorp修改 suncorp回复说他们没有report这个payments,没法修改。税局可以改 ...