澳洲Peronal tax return story

在澳大利亚税务




Just interviewed this one client, indian guy, late 20s. first of all, i have to say that i have nothing against indian people.
the appointment was scheduled at 5pm today, he came in 20 mins late, which is fine, i was happy to wait. as he is the last client of the day before i go home.
the indian guy sat down, made it clear to me that he wants as much refund back as possible. individual returns are always tricky to do compare to business returns. with business clients, the larger they are, they more i can differentiate myself from the rest. with individual returns, anyone out of school, who has read the tax pack back to front. probably can do it as well as me. the key here is patience and asking as many question as i possibily can to maximize deductions.
after 40 mins worth of questions and answers, we came down to a final refund, $2600, not bad for someone with no rental properties. the indian boy's face froze when he heard the refund. as if he has just been told the most ridiculous thing ever. He was quite straight forward, "this is not enough" he told me. every year, i come across one or two clients who tells me that after 40+ mins of interviewing, my work is simply not good enough. This is fine with me, its not enough to keep me awake at night.  Good thing majority of the clients are still satisfied with my work.
I quickly scanned through all the deductions, told him this is the maximum he can get back without receipts/spending for the year. "but my accountant did everything i told him last year, and he got me $3000+ in refund". the indian guy yelled. i smiled, and slowly explained to him that he is responsible for his own return, and accountant who does everything he asks without explaining the consequences is simply irresponsibly. feeling very tired at the same time, it is already 6pm, its been a long day of interviewing clients. good thing the chinese lady who just left was very nice and understanding.
"i will go speak to my friend, please donot lodge the return." the indian guy said after a few mins of awkard silence. i sighed, feeling abit disappointment that i didn't get through to him and my work wasn't appreciated.
I passed all the documents back to him and handed him a invoice for $40 for my time (it is an hour now including waiting time). "i want to save my $40, why are you charging me!" the indian guy yelled again. he seemed shocked by the invoice, couldn't understand why i have billed him after spending one hour with him. "your chinese brothers referred you to me, saying you are very good, you get more money back for me" he added.
"they referred you, because they appreciated what i've done" i replied. grabbing the invoice by and tossing it in the bin. "please go, hope your friend can help you better than i can" i said, while waving him to leave my office. "i am sorry, you are not happy, are you?" the indian asked. he looked abit worried now as if i would report him to the tax office. "you can go now" i said, didn't want to waste more time. as i still have a telephone interview at 7:00.
anyway, for those who read this, i hope you would appreciate your accountant by the time he spends explaining things to you. not by the amount of money he can get back for you. because any accountant can the amount you want back for you, but to us, they are just numbers.....we are not ultimately responsible for producing the evidence. so next time you come across a monkey who does everything you tell them, think twice, you are better off doing it yourself because he/she simply does not care enough to ask you any questions.

评论
现在一般会计报税也就收几十元,包括了interview 的费用吧。
不过如果对新客户有15-20分钟的free of charge稍微解释下客人应该很happy的。
我总认为,找会计,就要相信他;不相信总是doubt他的工作,还不如自己来好了。

评论
Don't deal with Indian anymore.

In this world, only Indians you can't do business with them.

评论
please do not be racial here

评论
他们就这样,印度人都不喜欢印度人的

评论
It's not racial at all.

You can make friends with them, but do not do business with them. You will be crazy cause every indian wants bargain with you, just like some aussi don't want do business with chinese, but I think indians like bargain more then chineses do.

评论


Can't agree more

评论
这样事太多了。我都习惯了

评论
David, 不用太生气,我很满意你为我做的tax return, 态度很好,解释得很清楚,谢谢你

评论
我认识很多印度人,  他们比中国人还中国人。 1澳元等于6块人民币,但等于40块左右印度币.  所以他们对一块钱都很认真的。 中国人已经活的很stress了。 但印度人更stress.

评论
Can I ask how much dedcution LZ claimed for the Indian client?

评论
Indians can never catch up Chinese

评论
They are too selfish,mean, and can not help to hide.
More than that, they suck but like ridicule other people.
They are good at tricking as well.
Agree what Hornsay said do not do business with them, and I would say never make friends with them. Support LZ.
澳洲中文论坛热点
悉尼部份城铁将封闭一年,华人区受影响!只能乘巴士(组图)
据《逐日电讯报》报导,从明年年中开始,因为从Bankstown和Sydenham的城铁将因Metro South West革新名目而
联邦政客们具有多少房产?
据本月早些时分报导,绿党副首领、参议员Mehreen Faruqi已获准在Port Macquarie联系其房产并建造三栋投资联

税务

税务

店里帮别人代售的货款税和gst怎么交?

澳大利亚我们礼品店M42.au有些多余的空间,最近想帮别的厂商代售一些产品,请问代收的这些货款税和gst也会算在我们头上吗?怎么做账比较好? 评论 厂商没有在澳洲注册公司注册GST?什么都没 ...

税务

买房贷款夫妻比例和报税比例请教

澳大利亚请教大拿们,如果夫妻一方工资收入高,假设买投资房贷款申请按80:20跟银行申请的贷款,那是不是每年报税时(负扣税,卖房时计算CGT)就必须按同样比例分摊? 评论 关键是有贷款 ...

税务

请教海外存款

澳大利亚请教: 如果以往年度报税的时候未提供非澳洲存款的信息,以后年度报税的时候想加上这个存款信息的话(因为也会有少量的利息收益),会有什么麻烦吗? 比如因为以前没声明,A ...

税务

投资房deduction的时间卡点问题

澳大利亚我知道关于投资房deduction的帖子很多,但是貌似没有讨论这个时间卡点问题 意思就是,我知道比如maintain和repair和pest control这些,可以算deduction 那么问题来了,如果投资房想收回自住, ...

税务

大家有没有收到这个邮件

澳大利亚DearXX, I am writing to you about your application for the 2021 COVID-19 Micro-business Grant for XX Service NSW regularly completes compliance reviews of NSW Government grant programs. We are now carrying out compliance reviews of the 2021 ...

税务

负扣税到底省了税没有?

澳大利亚不讨论折旧,只讨论负扣税。只是想讨论一下原理,非专业人士。理解可能有错误,请不要以此为依据。请教一下,看我的理解对不对。我的理解是,负扣税并没有省太多的税。假设房 ...

税务

投资房六年的税务问题

澳大利亚投资房有个六年法则,就是只要自己住过了,之后搬出来,在六年之内,还能算自住房。 我的情况是一开始这个房子是自住的,但是住了一年以后,我就搬出来了,这个房子给中介出租 ...

税务

自住房refianance的报税问题

澳大利亚请问自住房已经fully offset,refinance出来的部分用来放在家庭信托里面买投资房 请问自住房的这个refinance部分可以报税吗?可以报negative gearing吗? 如果信托里面的投资房是正现金流,那 ...

税务

退税中的状态

澳大利亚退税中的状态,outcome显示processing和balancing account有什么区别,分别各持续多久 评论 balancing account 通常是 ATO 已经完成你的退税。但ATO还不能把钱马上退给你, ATO再用一周时间问Center ...

税务

ESS Dividend被用来再买股票的缴税问题

澳大利亚向各位致敬先! 本人选择公司配股ESS产生的股息再用来买股票。当然这部分也会和其他的股票一样,在3年后到deferred tax point的月份/年度也会按规定缴税。所以我认为,在得到股息的月 ...

税务

Etsy网店报税疑问

澳大利亚想和国内的合伙人一起开一个Etsy网店,对于税务上有些疑问,希望得到专业会计的解答。 网店是我来注册开的,买家是付款给我的,但这些钱里面(假设扣除了Etsy抽成),我只能得到 ...

税务

ABN:Company vs Sole Trader

澳大利亚已有全职工作,目前有私活但不知道要开成有限责任公司形式还是sole trader。因为只能周末或者晚上做,一年收入估计就1-2万。因为工作内容如果涉及到金额较大的项目,会存在失误风险 ...

税务

请教一个定投基金卖出时的税务问题

澳大利亚5年前买了1万份某基金,每份10块,共10万块 4年前买了1万份某基金,每份15块,共15万块 现在基金每份20块,如果我想卖掉5千份,共计10万块。那这10万块里,税务上本金和CGT应该怎么算 ...

税务

公司名下房产出售税务问题

澳大利亚公司名下一处投资房,期间进行过装修,现在觉得出租一直很多事想卖掉。是不是除了公司所得税还要交增值部分的CGT?这感觉是一个收益交2次税,期间的装修费用是否也可以在计算 ...

税务

求教投资房转自住房税务问题

澳大利亚请教大神,假如今年买的投资房,装修了一下,没租出去,下一个财政年打算变成自住房,那装修的钱和买房的cost还能抵 这个财政年度的税吗?如果抵了,会对以后造成什么影响吗? ...

税务

div 293的问题,非常感激

澳大利亚看ATO网站写: If your income and concessional super contributions total more than $250,000, check if you have to pay Division 293 tax. 问题来了: 1 这个div 293的income是各种抵扣税之后的taxable income吗? 2 额外打的养 ...