澳洲无聊google了一下排名靠前的公立中学为啥review都很差,私校也不例外

在澳大利亚中学教育




悉尼搜了下strathfield girl, cheltenham girl,基本上都只有2.5左右
都说环境脏乱差,上完厕所不flush?老师很严格只追求学术成绩,
这是真实的吗

评论
老师很严格只追求学术成绩

评论
因为都是孩子大一点后,自己写的,他们就是爱抱怨 厕所怎么脏

看法比较极端。好就是很好很好,差就是很差很差。

不要被这些google review 影响了你的理性判断。



评论
你自己去公校看看呗。不会那么差,也好不到哪儿去。

评论
以前也有过跟楼主一样的疑问,后来发现对学校的那些google review,有实质的内容和评价的很少,更多的是在泄私愤、现粗劣。好多人明显就不可能是那个学校的家长(根据他们提及的学生性别)。

去学校的网页和open day看看,可以看出一个学校的脸面、软实力、气质气场。
放学时,去那个学校门口看看孩子们涌出时的样子,看看校服是否干净整洁,是否大声喧哗,有没有不给对面的行人让路。
向认识的学校家长打听学校的一些日常管理和教学的细节,尽量多问几个。



评论
可以想象

评论
我以前关注过一个非常好的学校,很是诧异这个学校的google review非常低分,才2点。过了几年再关注,过4了,发现一排人齐刷刷地在下面,并没给出任何经验分享,只打5分,就像商量好了一样

评论
确实应该实地考察几次,google review不论好坏都不一定客观

评论
Google review大多数是小朋友的trolls
但是如果具体的说某一个人或者事情 那可能还是有点问题的

评论
“老师很严格只追求学术成绩。” 现在对“严格”和“学术”定义真是宽泛呀,

评论
当初钉钉都被小孩投诉到下架整改了吧

评论
这也不能都怨学校,学生素质和家庭也有关系。有14岁孕女都不敢和家长说,同时被男朋友甩。自己的孩子自己多负责吧,不能都指望学校老师。卫生条件差是做为消费者的学生和家长花钱不到位吧。一分钱一分货一直都是这样。我觉得不花钱,就别挑剔了,不可能和花了比较多的相提并论。该投诉的是花了钱而服务不到位的。

评论
因为可以随便写,也不一定是本校学生或者家长写的吧

评论
有一些是确实不尽人意 反应在review上

但是 优秀的孩子孩子在大部分环境都会得到环境对他们的正向促进并且感到满足和归属。

举个极端的例子 阿桑奇打小跟母亲流浪 期间换了几十所学校  还换了几任父亲 他的姓是跟第二任父亲 第三位父亲是邪教教主。

这样的环境对成长有毒  但是不妨碍他光芒四射的才华


如果他来写那三十几所学校的review 会是啥样?



这里是james ruse 一个八年级孩子在google review上怼别人的review 有点意思:

for all those haters.
I'm currently a year 8 JRAHS student, and for all those people who say that JRAHS students have no social skills, you are so wrong. DEAD WRONG. If your claiming that we have no social skills just because we're good at academics, that just goes to show how much you don't know about us. Think about it: a lot of people in our school become doctors and lawyers, and to take on those professions, u gotta have a high sense of logic and emotional intelligence. As a doctor, you should always calm down your patient and talk calmly to them. How do I know this even though I'm not even graduated? I go to St John Ambulance Service Cadets, which is where I get my experience from. And from what I learnt there, to be a doctor, you gotta have top notch emotional intelligence to convey to your patient what you are thinking and how you're going to treat them. And if you're thinking that we're only good at academics, you are also DEAD WRONG. Our school is extremely talented, especially my grade. My grade has more than 30 people who have a AMEB degree in music. 80% of people in my grade play an instrument, and 60% play at least 2. The 30 people mentioned before that have an AMEB degree in music are all Lmusa's, Amusa's or Cmusa's. An example is me. I play the violin and piano, and I am about to take my grade 6 violin exam (I started last year), and I'm going to take my Lmusa piano exam at the start of next year. And just incase you think that we aren't sporty at all, you're also wrong. We have a lot of state sport players. Our school has set many sporting records in the NSWCHS area. Every year, we have more than 30 state swimmers and multiple state sport players in many different areas, such as tennis and volleyball. You might be thinking that I'm only talking about one grade, such as the year 11's, but no. My grade has 4 state basketball players, and more than 6 high level reps players. And that's just basketball. And yes, we don't have grade sport in years 7 and 8 unlike many other schools, but that's because our principal wants the best for us. We do take studying as a priority, but that doesn't mean that we don't have a personal life. And to all the haters out there that say that our parents force us to study, it's the other way around. Everyone in James Ruse Agricultural High School want to be the best at everything. At our school, we have a high level of competition with our peers, which defines us from other schools. Our students want to keep improving themselves, no matter what, and I know that from personal experience as I am a student there. Our CAPA studies are also very good, as the people in our school who take CAPA for HSC get pretty high marks. And once again, don't assume that JRAHS students are nerdy, because we're not nerdy. We just want to be the best at everything. All those haters out there only keep critiquing JRAHS because they are jealous. If you want to hate, first prove you can stay number 1 on the HSC leaderboard for 27 years first before dissing us.




评论
农业学校真的是卷王之王。
不过我喜欢这个孩子的描述 他在怼人的过程我们就能看到学校基本轮廓和氛围



评论
有意见的人才有动机去写负面评价,所以负评多很正常。

评论
都是学生自己写的 尤其是有男女校的 比如SBH抱怨隔壁女校把自己学校餐厅鸡翅膀都买光了 1星。

评论
土澳的娃还好意思说学校只在意学术成绩。。。。。。

评论

+1, 说的对!
澳洲中文论坛热点
悉尼部份城铁将封闭一年,华人区受影响!只能乘巴士(组图)
据《逐日电讯报》报导,从明年年中开始,因为从Bankstown和Sydenham的城铁将因Metro South West革新名目而
联邦政客们具有多少房产?
据本月早些时分报导,绿党副首领、参议员Mehreen Faruqi已获准在Port Macquarie联系其房产并建造三栋投资联

中学教育

中学教育

说到私校公校个人的一些观点

澳大利亚1. 市场经济,这么多人愿意多花钱的东西肯定是好的,但是一样数目的钱,对于每个家庭的意义是不一样的,所以结合自己的经济情况来看 2. 私校因为是收了钱的,所以相应的,提供的 ...

中学教育

砸了Year12 第一次assessments

澳大利亚有这经验的家长请指教 儿子的12 年级第一个assessments表现不佳, 都在70几到80几分之间 孩子感到非常失望,也同时失去了希望 如何帮助孩子重建自信 想读UNSW的物理治疗physiotherapy 还有希 ...

中学教育

数学几何题求助!

澳大利亚三角形ABC中,三条高如图交于点H,∠A的平分线AF依次交两条高BM、CN于D、E。 XE、XD为三角形DEH外接圆的切线。 K在BM上,且XK=XD。 L为CX与AH的交点。 求证:KL⊥AH。 评论 大概: 設 EKD = ...

中学教育

新州HSC的高考状元榜出来了(更新17/12)

澳大利亚花落各家尘埃定,膜拜一下牛蛙们lol https://www.nsw.gov.au/education ... -lists/first-course 4U数学:James Ruse 3U数学:The Scots College 3U英语:St Aloysius' College 2U英语:Cranbrook 2U物理:James Ruse 2U化学: ...

中学教育

Oh Yeah VS OMG

澳大利亚放假了,大家心情如何? 我的心情很矛盾 Oh Yeah 不用起早,不用接送了。 OMG要管理teen的手机,电脑,ipad,ps4,Netflix,YouTube等等等等了,想死的感觉。 不管的话,就可以天昏地暗无休 ...

中学教育

Brisbane Girls Grammar School 2024 ATAR亮眼

澳大利亚BGGS had one student attain the highest ATAR possible with the 2024 cohort's median ATAR sitting at a mighty 96.20. Brisbane Grammar School is proud to celebrate the exceptional ATAR results of our 2024 Year 12 students. Five BGS students a ...

中学教育

VCE 2024 Student honour roll

澳大利亚VCE 2024 Student honour roll 出来了,但是各媒体网站都要注册才能看。从VCAA找到了这两个文件,分享给大家 View the results of VCE high-achieving students https://www.vcaa.vic.edu.au/Docu ... 024StudentData.xlsx ...

中学教育

维州VCE:ATAR 90以上哪家强?

澳大利亚根据最近媒体报道,部分整理如下(未更新): Rank School Name % of Students with ATAR 90 1 Mac.Robertson Girls' High School 73.1% 2 Melbourne High School 71.89% 3 Presbyterian Ladies' College (PLC) 70% 4 Fintona Girls’ ...

中学教育

考一门外语对VCE最终成绩的影响

澳大利亚不懂就问:要想最终VCE成绩拿高分,是不是必须/最好选一门外语呢? 如果干脆不考外语的话是不是会很吃亏呢? 孩子马上要上7年级,我知道学好任何一门外语都不容易,不知道这个时 ...

中学教育

明天是不是VCE出成绩了?

澳大利亚几点出成绩? 第一批志愿什么时候有结果? 评论 明早7点出成绩 评论 比新州出成绩早几天。又是几家欢喜几家愁 评论 哇,又是一年VCE成绩要出来了。好快呀。 评论 预祝每个娃都心想 ...

中学教育

请推荐口碑好的IB补习

澳大利亚如题,多谢 评论 What subjects?It's hard to find IB tutors. My son just completed IB this year, waiting for results that is to be released on 18th, but his final school report has 7s throughout his subjects: English 1st language(SL) Bi ...

中学教育

11年级参加VCE成绩怎么算

澳大利亚孩子今年考了两门VCE,据她说这次只有raw study score,那是不是要到明年才会和其他参加2025年考试的孩子一起scaling呢? 评论 還以為你在悉尼呢 评论 我的理解是按今年相应vce科目的scal ...

中学教育

两个明年7年级的offer 怎么选

澳大利亚现在有两个中学选择-Richmond High 半精英,还有一个小的私校。 距离上,小私校更远点,要早起。车程单程一小时。钱不是主要问题。主要是女孩子,偏文科,也不是特别爱学习,爱运动 ...

中学教育

問一下7年級考試問題

澳大利亚是不是重點和私立中學的考試和測驗難度要比普通中學難上很多? 评论 这个问题很难回答... 即使完全相同教学内容和同样大纲标准,出题目的人可以让考试难度差很多的。 评论 這個是 ...