澳洲私校教育是否值得投资,article@SMH

在澳大利亚小学教育




今天SMH的首页money版有篇关于private school的文章,全文连接: http://www.smh.com.au/money/inve ... 20111015-1lq8g.html, 涉及私校优劣,return on investment,如何funding。

摘录一些主要的points

* After all, a year 7 student starting next year will cost $215,000 by year 12 if school fees keep rising at an annual rate of 6 per cent.

* Based on the "ample evidence" that private-school students will earn more "and are more likely to get top jobs", it calculated that "the average net return to investment in a private school education was 7 per cent for boarders and 13 per cent for day students".

* Above the fact that private school pupils were spending their school lives enjoying facilities normally far better than those available in state schools, these pupils benefited through improved pay in later life, and the financial return is broadly comparable (and probably higher) than returns on other capital."

* The bad news is the study was done 30 years ago and covered the 1970s when real private school fees were lower.

* It found public, yes public, schools produced better maths students than private ones.

* What gives the study cachet is that by only looking at the results for maths, it got around the problems of literacy being influenced by the home environment, other students, culture and even whether the school is in the city or the country.

* let's try a 2007 study. The Center of Education Policy (CEP) in the US reported in Time magazine: "Contrary to popular belief, we can find no evidence that private schools actually increase student performance.
Then it added "instead, it appears that private schools simply have higher percentages of students who would perform well in any environment based on their previous performance and background". Great. When private schools do better, it has nothing to do with them. But here's something to hang your hat on. "It appears private schools do more to develop students' critical-thinking abilities," the CEP says.

* Parents I know choose a school for lots of different reasons, ranging from how much they value religious instruction to the size of classes and even future business contacts. What they don't like to say too loudly is they don't want their kids mixing with the riff raff, preferring the educational equivalent of a gated community.
Don't be embarrassed, economists are on your side. In a submission to the Gonski inquiry into education funding, Deloitte Access Economics says the socio-economic background of the students is one of the most important influences on what it calls, yikes, "educational outcomes".
A high socio-economic background lifts all pupils, while a lower one drags everybody closer to the lowest common denominator.

可以确认的是fee的增长速度远高于inflation,
不能确认的是:毕业后找到好工作的比例,学习成绩好坏,是否全面发展,社会圈子

公校,私校永远是个没有结论的命题, 适合别人的不一定适合你,不适合别人的未必不适合你。只有选择了,才知道合不合适。

评论
没有结论的话题。

评论
这个投资回报是怎么计算出来的?
澳洲中文论坛热点
悉尼部份城铁将封闭一年,华人区受影响!只能乘巴士(组图)
据《逐日电讯报》报导,从明年年中开始,因为从Bankstown和Sydenham的城铁将因Metro South West革新名目而
联邦政客们具有多少房产?
据本月早些时分报导,绿党副首领、参议员Mehreen Faruqi已获准在Port Macquarie联系其房产并建造三栋投资联

小学教育

小学教育

请推荐暑期网上练习题

澳大利亚暑假太长了,不能总是天天玩pad,请推荐网上练习题,数学和逻辑都可以,免费收费都可以,过了年就五年级了,加分感谢! 评论 隔壁的Brilliant,做做logic 1或者叫foundation可以为thinki ...

小学教育

中文作业相关,台湾是中国的一部分吗?

澳大利亚孩子上中文学校,假期有点作业,是复习课文日月潭。我检查完后,孩子问了一个问题,台湾是中国的一部分,还是一个独立的国家?我听了就哈哈大笑。 我问他,你觉得呢。他说课文 ...

小学教育

家长们来说说,可以接受吗

澳大利亚前提是孩子小时候读书还可以,不是读书很差的孩子。 如果孩子长大以后做的是咖啡师,拧气球的entertainer, 厨师(或者烘培师)或者一些不需要高学历的工作,而不是去从事法,医,或 ...

小学教育

何为卷?

澳大利亚这几天好几个帖子都以卷为主题。究竟什么为卷?在说卷之前有没有想过究竟何种情况就算卷? 我来抛砖引玉一下。如果你想法不同,欢迎分享。如果你是阴阳怪气的,来吵架的,请为 ...

小学教育

2024 HSC 排名出来了

澳大利亚2024 HSC high school 排名出来了 1. north sydney boy 2. James Rouses 3. Sydney Grammar 评论 你这是怎么知道的? 教育局的系统又给黑了? 评论 4, Normanhurst’s 5,Reddam house 6. Baulkham hills 7. Hornsby girl 8. Nor ...

小学教育

考上Oc的我们来说说到底真题做得怎样

澳大利亚是真实的事情,匿名是因为不想大家看到ID. 孩子没去补习班但家里有比较厉害的Teen所以会帮老二时不时讲题。2021-2023的oc真题数学平均错9个,TS 平均错6-8个,英文因为没有全部真题所以 ...

小学教育

Principal award 算什么?

澳大利亚今天最后一天,去办公室拿了school report。成绩是预料中的不错。注意到有一个principal award。其实去年也有。 还有一个是principal reading award。 去年也有。 我一直觉得大多数小盆友只要升 ...

小学教育

女儿开始要求买比基尼了

澳大利亚11年级,放假后和同学去BEACH玩,打电话问说要买比基尼,我说拍个照来看看,一看就晕了,觉得11年级的孩子穿那么少不合适,就没让她买。 大家的看法呢? 评论 那小姑娘穿啥,连体 ...

小学教育

接下去准备全家和小孩只用普通话交流了

澳大利亚小学低年级,来了这里两年多,似乎已经是英文思维,脱口而出都是英文了。 明年转去一个新学校,基本上也没什么华人,现在给他报的线上中文课也越来越不喜欢了,这样下去肯定不 ...

小学教育

澳洲真的也是越来越卷了

澳大利亚刚刚岀生不久的孩子,父母居然也要早早把申请交到心仪的私校去排队了,是中学哦。真是难以想象。 评论 我知道怀孕就去排队的。 评论 男孩不是一直这样么 评论 這個沒用,都要出 ...

小学教育

儿子在学校有个好朋友特别爱撒谎

澳大利亚最近放学,小朋友经常跟我提起他的一个好朋友,印度裔,很聪明,但特别喜欢吹牛和撒谎。四年级,吹自己有一个2m follower的油管频道,家里有这有那的,很多一听就是撒谎,全班同学 ...

小学教育

求selective作文的优秀范文。谢谢

澳大利亚我的想法是,各种类型的优秀作文多让孩子看看,能背两句那就更好了。不知道哪位家长有资源,或有推荐的书籍。谢谢啦。 评论 你应该找不到,套路学校OC老师会教,0c班作业写作是大头 ...

小学教育

如果私校不要钱…

澳大利亚看到隔壁有帖子问关于Abbotts的,想到这问题,如果顶私通过考试等拿到了全额奖学金(等价于免费),对于考上顶私和顶精(英?)的学生来说,会怎么选?也就是说把钱这个因素排除 ...

小学教育

preuni奖学金

澳大利亚考到了50%折扣,有人知道最高的是多少折扣吗?75%?不知道今年有多少人考这个。 评论 食之无味,弃之可惜 评论 这个折扣不错啊,不知道preuni 还可以考奖学金。我们就是上传了oc of ...