澳洲关于加油加e10 91 还是98哪个最经济实惠的答案

在澳大利亚汽车





It's a question we get asked a lot and it's a question we thought it was about time that we answered. To find out we've fed our Holden Captiva 7 test car five different kinds of petrol over the past few weeks to see which was better.

The results might surprise you. An attractively priced family wagon, the seven-seat Captiva was perfect for the job. As well as E10 and standard Unleaded, we also decided to add Premium 95 and Premium 98 to the mix, along with the new E85, with 85 per cent ethanol mix that only some Saabs and Holdens can use.

There's nothing like being thorough. The young feller at the counter of our local servo was a bit concerned when we told him that we'd just filled up with E85. But we assured him it was okay, we knew what we were doing (some might disagree).

Seems some customers have mistakenly filled their cars with E85 with dire consequences if not designed to take the stuff. Think rough idling and engine failure ultimately. Holden has been making a big deal lately about its cars being E85 compatible, so our timing couldn't be better. Mind you, try finding a servo that stocks E85, it’s not easy they're few and far between.

OUR TEST CAR

The Captiva 7 CX is a mainstream, seven-seat family SUV. Priced to sell from $38,490, it has a 3.0-litre V6 petrol engine, all wheel drive and a five-star safety rating. The 3.0-litre V6, the smaller of the Commodore engines, produces 190kW of power and 288Nm of torque. It has a 65-litre tank and fuel consumption that is officially rated at 10.1 litres/100km giving it a theoretical range of 644km.

DID YOU KNOW?

Betcha didn't know the figures on fuel consumption stickers are based on Premium Unleaded 95. If you're like me, you just go looking for the cheapest fuel you can find when it comes to fill up. That's fine, but it means you're never going to see anything like the manufacturer's claim. Sucks doesn't it? The reason the test is based on Premium 95 is that not all cars will take standard unleaded, especially European cars.

ETHANOL

Ethanol is a type of alcohol. It is a renewable energy source and not as harmful to the environment as petroleum products. The US Environmental Protection Agency says one litre of ethanol reduces net emissions of COinf2 by over 90.9 per cent, so one litre of ethanol will save 2.11kg of COinf2.

Most cars built after 1986 can safely use petrol with ethanol added. In Australia, ethanol is made from sugar cane, red sorghum and the waste from starch production  not from food sources.  In the past ethanol has been blamed for being corrosive. But these days the ethanol sold in Australia must by law contain a corrosion inhibitor. Check to see if your vehicle is able to run ethanol blend fuel.

WHO'S RON?

Petrol carries a RON rating (Research Octane Number). The higher the number, the more compression the fuel will tolerate before it detonates. Generally fuels with a higher octane are used in high performance/high compression engines.

Most European cars are designed to run on Premium 95 RON unleaded because 95 is the standard over there. If you run your car on petrol with an octane rating below that recommended you might notice a knocking, rattling or a pinging sound which means the fuel is detonating instead of burning smoothly. This can damage your engine if you continue to use it.

URBAN MYTH

A trial undertaken in 1998 for the Federal Government showed that the use of E10 in vehicles designed for ULP increases fuel consumption by an average of 2.8 per cent but it varies from car to car. The NRMA's technical expert Jack Haley said it is a widespread but misguided belief that if you use a high octane fuel your car's performance will automatically increase. “You won't achieve any improved performance from using higher octane fuels unless your vehicle's engine is designed for them," he said.

ULP

Standard unleaded has an octane rating of 91. Locally produced vehicles, plus most Japanese cars, are designed to run on ULP and these don't generally benefit from premium or ultra premium petrol. The NSW Government had planned to phase out ULP this year but bowed to pressure because motorists whose cars won't take E10 would have been forced to pay more. Standard unleaded can however be hard to find and you might discover the unleaded that you're putting in your car already contains 10 per cent ethanol.

PULP

Premium unleaded petrol has an octane rating of 95. Most European cars are designed to run on PULP because that is the standard grade of petrol overseas.

UPULP

Ultra Premium Unleaded Petrol has an octane rating of 98. It's usually restricted to high performance sports cars. Shell used to sell 100 RON petrol which contained 5 per cent ethanol but stopped in 2008.

E10

E10 as its name suggests contains 10 per cent ethanol and has an octane rating of 94 or 95. It is fast becoming the default as standard unleaded becomes harder to find. In many cases it can be substituted for Premium in cars that require PULP. E10 delivers a bit more zip than unleaded, but your car will consume E10 at a faster rate because it does not contain as much energy and generally increases consumption by 1-3.5 per cent.

E85

E85 has an octane rating of 105. It's the newest addition to our service stations but only a small number of cars can use it, including some Saabs and Holdens. It is a cleaner-burning fuel that can enhance vehicle performance and reduce COinf2 emissions by up to 40 per cent.

Although there is less energy in a litre of E85, which means less range than petrol, the ethanol component has a higher octane rating, so you may notice an increase in power and overall performance. You might be surprised to learn that V8 Supercars have all run on E85 since 2009.

THE RESULTS

We clocked up more than 2600km over a four-week period, running the tank down to almost empty and refilling with a different fuel each time same car, same driver, same route each time. The prices quoted for fuel are all from the same outlet on the same day, which makes it a level playing field.

Apart from E85, there's not much between them in dollar terms. We got the best range and best fuel consumption from Premium 98 at 600km and 10.2 litres/100km. But of course 98 costs a lot more. The worst result came from E85 at 413km and 14.6 litres/100km. So unless you're particularly committed to saving the environment it's not the answer.

AND THE WINNER IS?

So, which is better E10 or standard unleaded? Ours was a real world test in real world driving conditions. While the figures may vary between different vehicles the relativities hold true. As our test confirmed expect better fuel consumption from ordinary unleaded at 11.1 versus 11.9 litres/100km.

Granted E10 is cheaper but the 2 cents a litre difference in price is simply not enough to warrant using E10 which costs $15.93 per 100km, compared to $15.08 for standard unleaded. E10 would have to be $1.26 a litre or less to justify swapping 7 cents cheaper not 2 as it usually is.

E85 on the other hand would have to be $1.03 to make it worthwhile 15 cents less. Based on our results you're better off sticking with standard unleaded, which will save you $170 over 20,000km or the course of a year. But it's interesting to note that running the good stuff (98), even though it's more expensive, will set  you back only 21 cents more per 100km or $41 over the course of a year.

来源: http://www.carsguide.com.au/car- ... -29451#.Vd_Ec_mqpBc

测试车是CAPTIVA,总体来说就是综合来看91还是比e10划算,每百公里便宜8毛多,但98也并不贵多少,每百公里贵两毛一而已,但是高标号汽油并不能带来更好的表现,除非引擎设计的就是要求高标号汽油。这是众多懂车帝都存在的误区啊。

评论
好长。。。等会看看

评论
不同车型不同发动机的测试结果不一样的,还得靠自己测才准。

评论
再来个比较个油站文章的!?

评论

这个估计很难有,毕竟同个油站的油品也不能做到每一油罐车都完全一样

评论
新马3,实测加95的貌似最划算,但是不知道加95的是不是没有必要啊,但是压缩比这么高又不敢加低的

评论

马三应该不会要求这么高吧

评论
我是只用91的

评论
加91、95、98基本上成本相差不大,标号高点的一箱油能跑远点,这个跟我的经验一致。
E10一点也不省钱,这也基本是定论,所以加E10真不明智啊,除非你的车就好那一口

至于说标号高的油并不能带来更好的表现(performance)? 我还是能感觉到不同,不知道他们说的performance具体是什么意思,仅指油耗吗?还是加速及引擎运转等?

评论
我以前也干过这种无聊事儿结果一样,91最经济,维州

评论
好吧,高压缩比的汽油发动机,用高标号汽油;低压缩比的汽油发动机,用低标号的汽油。具体的,自己去放狗吧----------是不是月经啊?

评论
车的说明书上说加什么就加什么呗 加高标号的没什么意思 不过现在家里俩车都是柴油的

评论
我的4.0 Falcon,试过几次98,真心感觉不出什么区别,后来就一直91了,E10一般是不碰的

我觉得有些地方美系车还是比较实在的,不像有些日系,买菜车加买菜发动机,还偏要95,的油,半年一次的保养,实在矫情

评论
Evoke 跑了8000,中间有2000是95 3000是98 剩下的是91,综合下来98确实会让引擎更平顺些,爬坡会有种幻觉转速低些。但是因为最近不开高速了,总开短途,看着那500公里11.5的综合油耗不爽,又滚回了91

评论
自测最准确 。
积碳多的车,相应会要求高一个号的油。
不同品牌。 不同标号多试试。
澳洲中文论坛热点
悉尼部份城铁将封闭一年,华人区受影响!只能乘巴士(组图)
据《逐日电讯报》报导,从明年年中开始,因为从Bankstown和Sydenham的城铁将因Metro South West革新名目而
联邦政客们具有多少房产?
据本月早些时分报导,绿党副首领、参议员Mehreen Faruqi已获准在Port Macquarie联系其房产并建造三栋投资联

汽车,澳洲华人

汽车

联合伺服系统的燃油质量不佳。

澳大利亚O.P.此帖子已编辑 gday all, 最近有一个巨大的问题,其中约95燃料来自北布里斯班联队服务站 它仍然与United争议,因为到目前为止,IM下跌了约1500美元,并计入了数额。由于其站点的污染 ...

汽车

2013 X-Trail内部锁定

澳大利亚O.P. 驾驶员侧门上的是一个锁定所有门的按钮。但是,驾驶员门仍然可以通过拉动手柄从内部打开。乘客侧门不能先禁用锁。是否可以像驱动器门那样从内部打开门? northernpixels写信.. ...

汽车

米其林PS5

澳大利亚O.P. 希望更换一组轮胎 米其林235x40x18 ps5 边缘尺寸为18x8.5 ET +35 5 x112 寻找安装时要获得的好价格 thaanks 使用Google cool。您在世界的哪一部分? 您期望低薪轮胎装配机需要多少护理? 像T ...

汽车

用什么代替汽车用

澳大利亚o.p. 嗨,惠普, 我正在寻找更换汽车的帮助, 我的当前汽车是2003年本田雅阁欧洲雅致133.000km自新产品以来拥有。 我已经看过多辆车,但仍然无法选择。 要求。 必须是全新的。 必须不 ...

汽车

破折号凸轮外电池

澳大利亚O.P. 嗨,无法弄清楚,所以发表了我的第一篇关于行车记录仪的文章。 我想要一个具有停车模式的行车记录仪,可以通过 G 传感器记录停车时发生的情况,或者停车时始终以降低的帧速 ...

汽车

Origin 360 EV 订阅服务

澳大利亚O.P. 这里有人通过薪水牺牲有任何经验吗? 我对MG4的快速报价很兴奋,我被引用了$ 207/wk(净税后节省)前12个月,每年减少约15%。 这里是否有人在订阅服务上拥有第一手经验或类似的 ...

汽车

马自达6在澳大利亚斧头

澳大利亚O.P. 马自达 6 在澳大利亚被砍掉 经过 22 年的销售,马自达 6 在澳大利亚已经走到了尽头,销量接近 15 万辆,传统中型轿车和旅行车的需求放缓. 去年,马自达长期运行的中型汽车在当地 ...

汽车

名爵温莎/五菱云EV/宝骏云

澳大利亚O.P.此帖子经过编辑 ,人们对电动汽车的兴趣日益加剧,这似乎是MG考虑在这里推出Windsor的绝佳时机。温莎(Windsor)也被称为印度尼西亚的Wuling Cloud EV和中国的Baojun Cloud,在国际上引起 ...

汽车

买了一辆拥有金融的汽车,仓的威胁

澳大利亚O.P. 大家好, 代表朋友发布此内容 去年年初,他买了一辆车 - 他做了车辆识别号检查(来自随机车辆识别号检查网站),显示出清晰的所有权等 快进一年半,他接到回购公司的电话,询 ...

汽车

转弯时在潮湿的道路上滑行

澳大利亚O.P.此帖子被编辑 我已经在去年转弯时在湿路上多次打滑我的汽车。我从来没有那么多次在过去的 上旋转360次,幸运的是没有人在路上。 我的汽车是老Holden Berlina 2006型号,我换了2年前 ...

汽车

Baleno作为第一辆车

澳大利亚O.P. 希望为孩子买第一辆车。她渴望开车,但对汽车的兴趣为零 - 小舱口,可靠,便宜的跑步将与我们追求的相关。主要是城市驾驶。 预算是15-17k至于可靠性以及是否有什么值得关注的 ...

汽车

妻子被倒车撞入未登记车辆

澳大利亚O.P. 妻子出了点小事故,倒车撞上了她后面的车。 另一位司机说他不会用保险追究,但我们还是拍了照片和他的驾驶执照。 决定查一下在维多利亚州道路上重新行驶,却没有这样的车辆 ...

汽车

如何疏通我的美式嘴阀门

澳大利亚O.P. 清除或解锁此问题的最佳方法是什么?今天早上我无法给轮胎充气 https://ibb.co/bKSyQhM 评论 去轮胎那里购买并购买一个新喷嘴。 评论 尝试按下中心销,因为它可以释放空气并希望将阻 ...

汽车

出租踏板车SYD

澳大利亚O.P. 希望在三月左右租用踏板车。一直在寻找租一辆踏板车,最好是在新南威尔士州班克斯敦地区附近。 我的搜索中弹出了一家商店:https://www.scooting.com.au/。 有人以前从他们那里租过踏 ...

汽车

又一张不公正停车罚单

澳大利亚O.P.这篇文章已编辑 大家好,我通常在早上 8.20 左右将我的妻子送到 Hoppers Crossing 车站。她在城里工作。犯罪那天,她真的迟到了,我没有把她送到下车区,而是在早上 8.50 的时候在车站 ...

汽车

在添加经销商配件之前接受交货

澳大利亚O.P. 您好。 我是那些迫切等待我的 PHEV 车辆及时交付的人之一,以便从 Novated Lease 的 FTB 节省中受益。 我知道配件会延迟向我交付汽车的过程。 从技术上来说,我可以先提车,然后让汽 ...

汽车

CX-9 的建造年份与新南威尔士州注册信息不同

澳大利亚O.P. 大家好, 我检查了一辆二手 CX-9(大约 30K 公里),构建板上的构建日期为 2022 年 2 月。然而,检查新南威尔士州网站上的 rego,它显示制造年份 = 2023。 私人卖家也不知道为什么,因 ...

汽车

涡轮增压压力调节故障

澳大利亚O.P. 嗨,自从我使用漩涡浴缸以来已经有一段时间了,很高兴回来。 我最近购买了 Topdon 扫描专业版,并对我的标致 308 2005 车型进行了诊断。 给了我 5 个错误的清单。 1.我的电池电压低 ...